Jewgle Perth

Perth's Real Jewish News

War Crimes?

It was reported today that Fremantle MP Mellissa Parke has delivered a Parliamentary speech in which she accused the Israeli military of “indiscriminate” killing of women, children and the disabled, and suggested the Jewish state has committed a “war crime” in the Gaza Strip.  Ms Parke’s Parliamentary statement is as follows:

In this international year of solidarity with the Palestinian people and as someone who lived in Gaza for 2½ years when I worked with UNRWA I wish to register my extreme concern about the Israeli bombardment of Gaza that has occurred over the past few days and which continues. So far, more than 170 Palestinians have been killed and 1,100 injured. The UN reports that 77 per cent of these casualties are civilians. By comparison, there have been no Israeli deaths from rockets fired from Gaza into Israel. The rockets from Gaza are not in any way justified and insofar as they threaten and harm civilians are illegal under international law. But these imprecise rockets fired by militants cannot be compared with the broad-scale bombing of a densely populated city by one of the largest and best equipped military forces in the world. As Noam Chomsky has said:

When Israelis in the occupied territories now claim that they have to defend themselves, they are defending themselves in the sense that any military occupier has to defend itself against the population they are crushing. … Call it what you like, it’s not defence.

The Israelis know every inch of Gaza and are capable of pinpointing their rockets. It is therefore inexcusable that a centre for disabled people was targeted. It is unacceptable that women and children are being killed indiscriminately as collateral damage. Collective punishment is not permitted under the Geneva conventions and is a war crime.

Following on from the recent terrible murders of Israeli and Palestinian teenagers, both sides should have shown restraint instead of allowing extremists to set the agenda. In my view a UN peacekeeping force is necessary to restore calm and provide a conducive environment for settlement talks.

Like any other person, Ms Parke has a right to her opinion.  However I cannot fathom how a respectable political party like Labor can tolerate such statements from one of their Members.  Gaza is an entity run by terrorists.  Hamas is classified by the Australian Government as a terrorist entity.  Their statements, language and intent is not discreet.  They call for the elimination of Israel and support their rhetoric by firing missiles, not hundreds, but thousands.  More than a thousand alone within the past week.  These missiles are intended to kill, and were it not for the Israeli Iron Dome defence technology, they would cause great harm.

Israel’s response is targeted, not indiscriminate.  It is necessary, but deeply regretful that Israel is forced to defend its citizens from intolerable war crimes.  It is even more regretful that Hamas places its infrastructure amongst the most vulnerable of its population.  Israel has acted demonstrably to avoid civilian casualty, and Israel has made it clear that calm will be restored when its population is no longer threatened by missile attack.

Israel’s predicament is clear to any rationale and informed person.  The language of the respective leaders of each population is enough alone to distinguish between  two sides of a conflict, one that values human life, and one that does not.

Any self respecting Australian should be outraged that a politician can stand in our Parliament and suggest Israel is committing war crimes in the wake and context of the offensive directed against it.  Ms Parke’s speech acknowledges that Hamas missiles are illegal, but she has carefully stopped short of accusing Hamas of war crimes.  Not so Israel.

Further to this, Western Australian’s should be alarmed that last Saturday there were people marching through the centre of Perth chanting “Long live the intifada”.  For the avoidance of doubt, that is people chanting in the Perth CBD that they support violent attacks against Israel, that they sanction suicide bombing and approve of murder.


I appeal to the people of Perth not stand by and allow our fellow citizens to march through our City and call for violence.  Anybody who advocates in support of terrorism does not deserve to be in Australia.

I appeal to members of the Labor Party and residents of the electorate of Fremantle, do not tolerate this moral inversion of the truth and this inexcusable demonisation of Israel from your elected representative.

We all need to be better informed.  The information below is a useful and succinct summary of the dilemma confronting Israel from the Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs:

Operation Protective Edge – Q&A

The main objective of Operation Protective Edge is to re-establish stability and quiet for the citizens of Israel once and for all. Israel cannot accept a reality in which millions of its citizens are subject to the whims of radical Islamic terrorist organizations.
  • How did it all start?

Between 12 June and 7 July, Hamas and other terrorist organizations in the Gaza Strip fired 300 rockets at Israeli civilians. Although Israel showed great restraint and called for the cessation of the rocket attacks, Hamas kept firing them indiscriminately into Israeli towns and cities around the country. No country in the world would accept such a reality, and Israel is no exception.

However, after three weeks of restraint, and the continuation of incessant rocket attacks, Israel was left with no other alternative but to respond in order to restore the safety of its civilian population.

  • What is Israel’s goal?

The main objective of Operation Protective Edge is to re-establish stability and quiet for the citizens of Israel once and for all. Israel cannot accept a reality in which millions of its citizens are subject to the whims of radical Islamic terrorist organizations, under immediate threat with as little as 15 seconds to find shelter from incoming missiles.

  • How does Israel plan to achieve this goal?

The only way to restore quiet to the citizens of Israel is by going after the Hamas aggressors who are entrenched in Gaza. Operation Protective Edge is aimed at significantly degrading Hamas’ missile capabilities and destroying the terrorist infrastructures directed at Israeli civilians. Israel is not looking for a short-term understanding but wants a long-standing solution for the sake of the safety of its citizens.

  • What are the targets of the Israeli airstrikes?

As part of the operation, the IDF is selectively targeting mobile and concealed rocket launchers, Hamas leadership facilities, attack and smuggling tunnels, terrorist compounds, training sites, communications facilities, air defense elements and additional sites used for terror activities targeting Israel, including command and control centers.

  • What are the long-term objectives of Hamas?

Hamas is similar to other radical jihadi movements like al-Qaeda, ISIS and Boko Haram in its complete intolerance of the presence of non-Muslims in the Middle East. Therefore, it is no surprise that Hamas maintains close operational ties with jihadi terrorists in Sinai, including for weapons smuggling, and is getting weapons and support from Iran.

According to Hamas’ ideology, Israel has no place in the world and Hamas’ declared goal is the destruction of the Jewish state. This is exemplified in the organization’s covenant: “Hamas strives to raise the banner of Allah over every inch of Palestine” [meaning all of Israel, the West Bank and Gaza]. In addition, the organization promotes an antisemitic ideology that glorifies jihad and the killing of Jews.

  • Why is Hamas shooting rockets at Israeli towns?

Hamas’ tactic of firing rockets at Israeli civilian communities did not end when Israel left Gaza completely in 2005, but rather intensified. Because of its commitment to the annihilation of Israel, Hamas views every Israeli man, woman and child as a legitimate target of its terrorist attacks by missiles, suicide bombings, murder and abductions.

Hamas leaders have repeatedly stated that “all of the Israelis are legitimate targets” (Hamas spokesman Sami Abu-Zuhri, 8 July).

In recent years, the Hamas terrorist organization invested heavily in offensive weapons, bringing the number of missiles aimed at Israeli towns to around 12,000.

By firing rockets at densely populated areas in Israel, Hamas terrorists are attempting to cause as many civilian deaths as possible. Hamas’ indiscriminate rocket fire is consistent with its ideology, which sees Israeli civilian casualties as military successes.

  • Why have there been relatively few Israeli casualties so far in this confrontation?

Due to the growing missile threat, Israel invested huge resources in establishing a two-fold defense system for its citizens:

1. Israel developed the Iron Dome missile defense system, which throughout this confrontation has provided outstanding protection to Israeli civilians, saving the lives of hundreds or more Israeli civilians.

2. Israel constructed a vast infrastructure of shelters and set up an early warning system enabling its civilians to find quick cover when terrorists launch their missiles.

Were it not for the effective deployment of Iron Dome and the shelters, the number of Israeli civilian casualties in this conflict would be very high.

  • Why have civilians in Gaza been hurt?

The civilian casualties in Gaza are a direct result of Hamas’ tactic of using the Palestinian civilian population as human shields for its terrorist activities. Hamas is committing a double war crime by deliberately targeting Israeli civilians while at the same time embedding its weapons, leaders, operatives and infrastructures in the midst of uninvolved Palestinian civilians. Hamas bears full responsibility for the civilian casualties in the Gaza Strip.

Moreover, Hamas is also investing all of its resources in acquiring and producing weapons and rockets for attacking Israel, instead of caring for the welfare of the population of Gaza.

In a show of utter disregard for the safety of its own civilian population, Hamas’ Ministry of the Interior in Gaza has instructed residents not to heed Israel’s warnings about impending attacks. Hamas also urges residents to actively form human shields, thus deliberately exposing them to grave danger.

  • What measures is Israel taking to minimize civilian casualties in Gaza?

Israel is doing the utmost to reduce to a minimum the harm caused to uninvolved civilians. It does so by employing stringent target selection procedures, by warning residents about impending strikes using phone calls, text messages and leaflets and by firing warning shots.

Israel does all this despite significant tactical costs, foregoing operational opportunities and refraining from attacking known terrorist hideouts and weapons caches located in dangerous proximity to civilians.

  • Why is it so difficult to de-escalate the situation?

The main reason it is so difficult to bring an end to the violence is Hamas’ lack of motivation to do so.

Hamas’ experience so far has shown it that it is not considered by the international community as accountable for its violations of basic morality and of international law.

  • Are the current events part of a cycle of violence?

One can be tempted to view this confrontation as the latest round in an imagined “cycle of violence”. However, nothing could be farther from the truth since there is no symmetry between Israel and Hamas.

Israel left the Gaza Strip completely in 2005 and has no claims on the territory besides the wish to see it develop as a peaceful and prosperous neighbor. If Hamas and the other terrorist organizations disarmed and stopped their attacks, Israel would have no reason to respond.

Yet instead of developing the Gaza Strip, Hamas violently seized control of the territory, turned it into a terror base and established a terrorist dictatorship whose declared goal is the destruction of Israel.

2 thoughts on “War Crimes?

  1. The only ones who commit war crimes is Hamas.
    Israel like any other nation on earth has the right to defend itself.
    Anyone denying |Israel’s right to defend itself is a war criminal as this person or persons advocate mass suicide of the Jewish people. My message to all peace loving citizens of this country is, “evil begets evil” and stop crying about the poor Palestinians who live in splendour and being well fed by UNWRA . Those people should look into the plight of the poor Syrian refugees in Jordan, the mass killings that went on in Syria and all the suffering that’s going on in Africa. G-d bless Israel!

  2. G-d bless Israel and keep its citizens safe from the terror of Hamas.
    War criminals is Hamas who indiscriminately fire rockets and missiles at civilians in Israel.
    Israel warns Gazan’s to vacate buildings before it bombs them.
    No other nation on earth has done this, not the Allies during WW2 when they carpet bombed Germans towns, and not the Nazis when they bomb London. Nor the USA in Vietnam.
    This world is full of hypocrites and should be ashamed of themselves.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *